He noted that the style of the spear tips the solutreans used was like that of the clovis culture in the americas, who are the oldest culture on the continent. I think the solutrean hypothesis is basically true, and probably has more evidence for it than the beringian land bridge theory had for it when it was first adopted. The solutrean hypothesis suggests that the solutrean group migrated to north america during the ice age approximately 15,000 17,000 years ago via a land bridge that existed from europe to the north american continent. May 18, 2019 criticisms of the solutrean hypothesis.
The solutrean hypothesis sh for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that. Mar 03, 2012 the solutrean hypothesis of the first peoples to inhabit north america is getting positively respectable to the point that the washington post has deigned to publish a longish article on the topic radical theory of first americans places stone age europeans in delmarva 20,000 years ago. It holds, essentially, during the last ice age, anatomically modern humans from europe crossed via an ice bridge or over open water to north america. Of or relating to the old world upper paleolithic culture that succeeded the aurignacian and was characterized by new stone. Ancient native boys genome reignites debate over first. Solutreanclovis connection in american colonization.
New evidence supportsdenies the solutrean hypothesis updated. May 28, 2015 solutrean hypothesis stands on its own two feet, even if it does require compounding presumptions as most any prehistorical theorems will across atlantic ice postulates one possible concept as far as how the voyage was made but even if we disregard that, it cites a base of technological evidence that is extremely compelling. If solutrean boat people washed up on our shores, they suffered cultural amnesia, genetic amnesia. Aug 23, 2018 morphological and archaeological studies suggest that the americas were first occupied by nonmongoloids with australomelanesian traits the paleoamerican model, which was subsequently followed by southwest europeans coming in along the pack ice of the north atlantic ocean the solutrean model and by east asians and siberians arriving by way of the bering strait. A recent canadian documentary promoted a fringe idea in american archaeology thats both scientifically wrong and racist. Stanford and bruce bradley, suggests that the solutreans, a group of prehistoric spaniards from around 15,000 bce traveled across the atlantic and gave rise to the clovis culture of the americas around 11,000 bce. Problems with stanford and bradleys proposed solutrean colonisation of north america. An apparent trend in the criticism of the solutrean hypothesis is that stanford and bradley overstate the similarities between solutrean and clovis, and understate. Elk antlers the partial skeleton of the 1yearold boy, called anzick1, was discovered when a frontend. Does the fan base of the solutrean hypothesis change if. Oct 19, 2018 the bipointed blades found in chesapeake bay bear a staggering similarity to other stone age weapons found across the atlantic ocean. They brought the solutrean high hunting culture, with its characteristic and advanced stone tool set to north america, where it became known as the. Apr 26, 2017 morphological and archaeological studies suggest that the americas were first occupied by nonmongoloids with australomelanesian traits the paleoamerican hypothesis, which was subsequently followed by southwest europeans coming in along the pack ice of the north atlantic ocean the solutrean hypothesis and by east asians and siberians arriving by way of the bering strait.
The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from southwestern europe to north america during the last glacial maximum. S tanford and bradley argue supports the hypothesis that the solutrean is. Who the first americans were remains an unanswered and much debated question. Jan 28, 2016 if x2a was the result of a solutrean migration during the pleistocene 23,500 to 18,000 years ago with a landing base in newfoundland or someplace on the east coast, the oldest and deepest lineages should be found in the eastern population, not on the west coast. According to the solutrean hypothesis, the first americans were stone age europeans who came to north america several thousand years earlier than the ice bridge theory proposes. Jennifer is a geneticist who specialises in the study of human variation among contemporary and ancient populations. The hypothesis is challenged by large gaps in time between the clovis culture and solutrean eras, a lack of evidence of solutrean seafaring, lack of specific solutrean features and tools in clovis technology, the difficulties of the route, and other issues. Its notable proponents include dennis stanford of the smithsonian institution and bruce bradley of the university of exeter. The solutrean hypothesis is trapped on all sides technological parallels between clovis and solutrean are overstated, a transatlantic crossing is hard to fathom or prove, clovis mtdna has east eurasian affinities, clovis autosomal dna has south american affinities, prelgm south siberian dna has west eurasian affinities making a direct. Meltzer is among those still skeptical of the solutrean hypothesis, citing the scant evidence. What is the current status of the solutrean hypothesis. White nationalists and the solutrean hypothesis jason colavito.
Radical theory of first americans places stone age. The solutreans then migrated down into the north american continent, establishing the first known inhabitants of the continent. The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture has received numerous challenges and critiques. Nov 29, 2014 the solutrean hypothesis is trapped on all sides technological parallels between clovis and solutrean are overstated, a transatlantic crossing is hard to fathom or prove, clovis mtdna has east eurasian affinities, clovis autosomal dna has south american affinities, prelgm south siberian dna has west eurasian affinities making a direct. The solutrean hypothesis posits that a population derived from the solutrean culture of western europe may have crossed the north atlantic ocean along the edge of pack ice that extended from the atlantic coast of france to north america during the last glacial maximum, before 17 kya. Mar 10, 2014 the solutrean hypothesis suggests europeans whose native habitats had been rendered dry, barren wastelands in the wake of the last glacier maximum, were drawn to the edges of the massive ice sheet connecting europe to america because there was noticeable activity in the form of seals, walruses, fish, etc at ice edge.
Solutreans may have arrived in america earlier than. The peopling of the american continents social sciences. Solutrean definition of solutrean by the free dictionary. The occasion is the publication of a book by dennis stanford, an anthropologist at. Clovis and solutrean spear points not only look alike, they are made the same unusual way. Solutrean definition of solutrean by merriamwebster. See solutrean hypothesis the only sure way we are going to find out how humans came to north america is to build a time machine. Solutrean synonyms, solutrean pronunciation, solutrean translation, english dictionary definition of solutrean. Ellen lloyd who the first americans were remains an unanswered and much debated question. Oct 24, 2015 the solutrean hypothesis suggests that the solutrean group migrated to north america during the ice age approximately 15,000 17,000 years ago via a land bridge that existed from europe to the north american continent. A controversial new archaeological theory says the continents earliest humans may have come from europe, not asia march 18, 2012, 12. The solutrean hypothesis, what the evidence really says. Surprising news about the solutrean hypothesis should give.
The americas were the last of the continents on our planet to be colonized and settled by humans. Problems with stanford and bradleys solutreanclovis hypothesis. The solutrean hypothesis, first put forward in the 1930s and revived more recently by dennis j. The oldest wellcharacterised archaeological culture in america is the clovis culture. Cbc under fire for documentary that says first humans to. The us federal government, state and local governments do not collect data on race and tax revenue.
They brought the solutrean high hunting culture, with its characteristic and advanced stone tool set to north america, where it became known as the clovis culture. The solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from southwestern europe to north. The solutrean hypothesis claims that the clovis people, the makers of the earliest known stone tools in the americas, were the cultural and biological descendants of the solutrean peoples of southwest coastal europe. Alternatively, the more conventional hypothesis suggests that people associated with the clovis culture were from asia by way of the bering strait. This idea has its roots in the 19thcentury when archaeologists such as cc abbott postulated that. In fact, there is genetic evidence that only the solutrean hypothesis explains. The solutrean hypothesis is a controversial proposal that peoples from europe may have been among the earliest settlers in the americas, as evidenced by similarities in stone tool technology of the solutrean culture from prehistoric europe to that of the later clovis toolmaking culture found in the americas. In a paper published in nature today, titled the genome of a late pleistocene human from a clovis burial site in western montana, by rasmussen et al, the authors conclude that.
The archeological community has been consistently skeptical of the solutrean hypothesis. Kevin macdonald the solutrean hypothesis of the first peoples to inhabit north america is getting positively respectable to the point that the washington post has deigned to publish a longish article on the topic radical theory of first americans places stone age europeans in delmarva 20,000 years ago. Pdf the solutrean hypothesis for the origin of the clovis. Native american haplogroup x2a solutrean, hebrew or.
Some people believe that the first peoples of the americas were the solutreans, a stone age people from france and spain who existed around 25 kya, and ended 16,500 ya. Nov 16, 2018 the solutrean clovis connection more formally known as the north atlantic iceedge corridor hypothesis is one theory of the peopling of the american continents that suggest that the upper paleolithic solutrean culture is ancestral to clovis. White nationalists and the solutrean hypothesis jason. Genetic study kills off solutrean hypothesis scienceblogs. Is the solutrean hypothesis correct evolution, morphology. Oftrepeated contraassertions, predominantly from archaeologists, range from.
The solutrean hypothesis the alternative hypothesis. The solutrean hypothesis first came about in the 30s by archaeologist frank hibben. Estimates range from as late as 12,000 bc to as early as 18,000 bc for the date of human arrival, depending on what site you are looking at. The solutrean hypothesis is a legitimate archaeological hypothesis. This hypothesis has received numerous critiques, but little objective. This hypothesis contrasts with the mainstream view that the north american continent was first reached after the last glacial maximum, by people from north asia, either by the bering land bridge i.
The solutrean hypothesis is a minority opinion concerning the human settlement of north america. The solutrean hypothesis sh for the origin of the clovis archaeological culture contends that people came from south. It is a space where they can share, communicate and connect with anyone or everyone. Did the mysterious first americans arrive in watercraft. The solutrean hypothesis top that native americans today are descendants of peoples who migrated from eastern asia is firmly established and no longer controversial daniel defoe once argued they were descendants of the carthagenians. The idea of a clovissolutrean link remains controversial and does not enjoy wide acceptance. So this data here is based on multiple sources to come up with an estimate of net fiscal. There are several promising theories, but several scientists say conclusive evidence is still missing. Feb, 2014 the solutrean hypothesis starts from a comparison with spearheads from the solutrean culture in southwest europe, noting that certain solutrean points have an outline that is similar to that of. Atlantic ocean the solutrean hypothesis and by east asians and siberians arriving by way of the bering strait. Basically, all of the signals are pointing to asia as the origin of the first americans. The solutrean hypothesis emerged in the 1930s when archaeologist frank hibben noted that the style of stone points used by the newlydiscovered clovis culture, then the oldest known in the americas, bore what seemed to him to be a striking similarity to stone points made by the solutreans, a stone age people occupying spain and france around 25,000 years ago.
Were the same people responsible for creating both. Aug 15, 2016 in its modern iteration, this idea is known as the solutrean hypothesis. It just isnt actually supported by ancient dna at this point and it is somewhat unlikey this will change. A view from the ocean kieran w estley 1,2, and justin dix 3 abstract one current hypothesis for the pleistocene peopling of the americas invokes a dispersal. Solutrean definition is of or relating to an upper paleolithic culture characterized by leafshaped finely flaked stone implements. If solutrean boat people washed up on our shores, they suffered cultural amnesia, genetic amnesia, dental amnesia, linguistic amnesia and skeletal amnesia. Just like afrocentrists have cockamamie theories, so do eurocentrists. Solutrean hypothesis open research exeter university of exeter. The solutrean hypothesis were europeans the first n. The solutrean hypothesis, first proposed in 1998, is a hypothesis about the settlement of the americas that claims that people from europe may have been among the earliest settlers of the americas. The solutrean hypothesis, first proposed in 1998, is a controversial theory about the settlement of the americas, which argues that europeans, originating from the solutrean culture on the iberian peninsula, were the first, or among the first, settlers of the americas. To stanford and bradley, this was a powerful clue that prehistoric explorers had come from europe and brought with them the technology that transformed stone age america. There is dispute about the dating of the tools the team cites.
799 399 189 1607 367 234 695 780 661 133 160 957 390 260 1070 1547 1339 738 225 588 158 784 530 183 4 248 1356 1542 1158 1278 1659 396 684 836 1616 1130 1164 1213 1248 486 121 403 1050 1420 1493 395 857 755 545